Funny American Idol 5 Auditions, Part Three
This article has been re-posted at Idle Idols, the site for the funniest American Idol auditions.
My usual disclaimer:
The only episodes of American Idol that I watch are the audition episodes. Why? Because watching people sing is less-than-enthralling for me. What I do enjoy, however, is watching people not sing for judges. Even in the audition episodes, my mind quickly starts to wander when a good singer starts belting it out.
American Idol 5 auditions continued tonight, showing yet another bunch of "singers" trying out in Greensboro, NC.
Here is the list of the most interesting auditions from this third audition episode:
Rhonetta Johnson #64390 — Rhonetta was clearly the producers' choice for this episode. They placed her last so that they could promo her audition the entire two hours. Rhonetta chose to wear a silver tube top, a too-short white skirt, and sparkly, silver boots. And when I say "too-short skirt," I mean completely unflattering. I'm no fashion expert, but you know you have a problem when your belly is pushing your tight skirt down in the front. Paula asked, "It says you think you could be bigger than J. Lo and Janet." Simon quickly replied "Well, in a way, she is." In her post-audition ranting, she said that Paula "could never be famous." Here's Rhonetta Johnson's audition video:
- Marcus Behling #63298 — Marcus claimed to have "won approximately three talent shows." Marcus' goal seemed to be to impress the judges by singing each note for as long as possible. For instance, it took him 14 seconds to sing the words "She's out of my life." Randy laughed and said that the song was going to take two hours at that pace. When asked if he had taken vocal lessons, he said that he was using the Randy and Paula DVD (Ultimate Voice Coach – Learn To Sing Like A Star!). This made Simon's day, as he couldn't get over that fact, and he noted that it was the best birthday he has ever had. Post-audition, Marcus took the DVD out on the street and beat it to death with a hammer. Watch Marcus' audition and subsequent DVD destruction.
- Sabrina Oakley #60731 — Sabrina referred to herself as "Sabrina, the teenage witch." Simon quickly noted, "Well, let's lose the 'teenage'." She claimed on her application that men always hit on her and when this was mentioned, she said something I found to be incoherent. Closed captioning tells me that she said "So I'm hoping Simon will hit on me." Sabrina sang off-key, so Simon said that it was less "hitting on" and more like "hitting." Simon also just had to point out that she was "more Jerry Springer Show than American Idol," and he actually had a valid point there. Simon later punctuated his sentiment by yelling "Y'all stole my sister!" Sabrina snapped and screamed about how she hated Jerry Springer.
- Shawn De Salazar #61172 — Shawn dressed formally for his audition and brought with him a large poster chronicling his "life story." Apparently, he was born the week before, because there wasn't much on there other than him traveling to Greensboro and wanting to get onto American Idol. Shawn was "on a mission to bring back standards" back to American Idol, and he sang one: That Old Black Magic. While he didn't sound horrible, Simon said that he sounded "distinctly average," and compared him to one of those singing waiters you might see in an unpopular restaurant. Shawn's little brother was pretty outspoken about his talents, and he seemed pissed after Shawn was turned down. "I think it's baloney . . . And you know what? Who needs American Idol?"
- Richard Garland #61769 — Richard brought his ventriloquist dummy Scotty. Unfortunately, Scotty did not join in on the singing portion of the audition, but he did compliment Paula before being shoved back into the box. As Richard left, Simon advised him that "There's nothing wrong with working with a dummy." Paula gave a knowing look, and said "I work with them all the time! All the time!"
- Ronda Jones #60123 — Ronda had a distinctly high-pitched voice that sort of reminded me of a mix between Spongebob's friend Sandy and Annie Potts (the actress you'd recognize as secretary Janine in Ghostbusters). Randy asked her what she was going to sing to prove that she was the next American Idol, and Ronda berated him for putting a lot of pressure on her. Ronda sang some Backstreet Boys, and Simon complained that it "sounded just like the original."
Sergeant Steven David Jr. #60531 — Steven is in the International Guard, and he openly drooled over Paula before his audition. In fact, he bet Paula that she would have to dance with him if he had a good singing voice, and Simon accepted the offer. Paula was skiddish about the whole ordeal, likely due to the whole Justin Guarini psuedo-scandal. Steven had a good singing voice and got through, so Randy and Simon dragged Paula up to dance with him. As Steven left, Ryan escorted his wife through the door. Paula berated him for doing that. Watch Sgt. Steven David Jr.'s audition.- Donny Meacham #60522 — Donny (attempted to) sing Bridge Over Troubled Water, but it didn't go well. Simon's vote? "Well, you just murdered one of the most beautiful songs of all time. You went from torture to murder."
- Chonna Clepper #63506 — After a cold interview with a "short" Ryan, Chonna entered the room wearing lingerie. She said that her (ex-stripper) mom went to a lot of lingerie shows and picked up a lot of stuff. Since the ex-stripping mom was doing it for her kids, the judges didn't berate the situation. (We won't get into that here.) Still, one has to wonder why one would choose lingerie for an audition. Simon later said that Americans have weird ideas about lingerie, and if he saw that, he'd say "Back in the bathroom, sweetheart!"
- Cedrick Robinson #60868 — Cedrick was apparently Fantasia's relative. You know how some families have a ton of musical talent in them from the youngest child to the oldest great-grandparent? Cedrick proved that this isn't the case here. After Cedrick tried some fancy voicework to end his song, Randy told him, "You went through about twelve keys right there." Cedrick said that he had been singing since he was three, but Simon replied that his voice hadn't changed much.
- Jimmy Crabtree #64076 — Jimmy has to be one of the least excited people to audition for American Idol. He spoke with a monotone voice, even when entering the room. Simon informed him that he had the "personality of a hippo."
- Sammy Neighbors #67572 — As far as effeminate, overweight men go, this is one of the best to audition for American Idol. Sammy clearly couldn't carry a tune if it was handed to him in a basket, but his stage presence was . . . undeniably unique. He chose to "sing" A Whole New World. He placed a red blanket on the stage as the magic carpet, but the magic carpet soon became a cape, a shawl, and possibly discarded lingerie in an imaginary striptease . . . I'm not sure about that, but I'd rather not examine it further. Also helpful was the literal pointing during the line "a new fantastic point of view." Sammy then broke into Paula Abdul's "Straight Up," and he shook his booty in a disturbing manner. Paula look away, frightened, but it wasn't clear if it was due to the butchering of her song or the booty shaking. Simon called Sammy "Sylvester Stallone's younger sister singing Paula Abdul ." Here's Sammy Neighbor's audition video:
- Seth Strickland #64916 — Seth was, apparently, a huge Michael Jackson fan. He had Jackson's clothes, and even attempted a couple of the dance moves. Unfortunately, Seth didn't seem to bring anyone's singing talent with him. In the middle of his song, he gave out an "Oh, crap" that was entertaining. Watch Seth Strickland's audition.
This post will be updated as pictures and video clips are available online, so bookmark this page or the American Idol page.
Crystal Parizanski
The 1½ Calorie Breath Mint
Brice Mellen